Whenever a tropical system named Marie enters the Pacific, ears perk up, and expectations for Southern California surfers go through the roof.
The legendary Hurricane Marie swell of 2014—often cited as the modern benchmark for epic summer surf—set an incredibly high standard. So when Hurricane Marie 2.0 recently lit up the coast, the inevitable question arose: Was the new Marie better than the original?
In a recent video breakdown by Surfline, Forecaster Schaler Perry analyzed the two historic events. According to Perry, comparing the swells ultimately comes down to quantity versus quality. Click play for the breakdown below.
“Marie 2014 is already the benchmark,” Perry explained in the video. “So you get another Marie this year and naturally there’s comparisons… I think there was some nuance that made Marie 2.0 better for some places.”
The 2014 Marie delivered absolute “ruler edge perfection” and massive size to a select few iconic spots like Newport Point and Malibu. However, that immense energy was mostly consolidated into a single, overwhelming day.
“The 2014 event was just too big,” Perry noted, adding that for most beach breaks, it was impossible to paddle out.
Related: Hurricane Marie 2026: Did the Swell Live Up to the Hype? (Photo Gallery)
By contrast, Marie 2.0 was defined by its incredible duration and favorable track. As the cyclone meandered northwest at a sluggish six knots, it pushed a consistent, highly manageable swell toward the coast for four straight days.
“You wake up on Saturday it’s pumping, Sunday still pumping, Labor Day Monday… still going,” Perry said. “When it comes to summer surf, I haven’t seen anything like it so far during my tenure. It’s just been pumping. This happens once every 30 years.”
Also, the new swell shifted directions from southeast to southwest over its lifespan, allowing a much wider variety of breaks across Southern California to fire at different times.
Related: Hurricane Marie Never Made Landfall in California. She Destroyed the Coast Anyway.
Which begs the question…Was Marie 2.0 better than the OG?
If you scored the wave of your life at Newport Point in 2014, perhaps not. But for the average surfer who enjoyed four consecutive days of pumping, approachable barrels, the sequel might just take the crown.
As Perry concluded: “I guess I’m a quantity over quality guy.”
What’s your take?
Original Post from this site